From Mogadishu to Melbourne – rediscovering place in a globalized world

Review by Dr. Firouz Gaini
February 10, 2020

Being-here: Placemaking in a World of Movement

by Lems, Annika
Published 2018

Berghahn Books

buy on Amazon
In her monograph, Annika Lems searches for answers to questions about the meaning of place, home and memory through the biographical narratives of three persons who left Somalia in early adulthood and quite accidentally ended up in Melbourne (Australia) after complicated trails through different countries. The main body of the book, nine chapters organized in two parts entitled ‘Emplacement’ and ‘Displacement,’ discusses and analyzes the experiences and life stories of the two main protagonists, Omar and Halima, who, with their storytelling (or ‘story-building’), ‘have opened up the possibility of understanding human emplacement as located at the crossroads between the closeness of place and the infinity of the universe’ (213). In this seminal publication in the framework of existential phenomenological anthropology, Lems links Sein (Being) and Da (Here) in her theoretical illustration of the relationship between space and place in a globalized world. A perspective reflecting her empirically-based effort to rethink the meaning of place in dominant contemporary anthropological scholarship. Storytelling, she says, ‘is another crossroad at which places and memories from the past and impressions and experiences from the present begin to leak into each other’ (216). Drawing on anthropological and philosophical studies of space and place, with focus on the work of existential and philosophical thinkers, for instance Heidegger, Casey, Bachelard, who, she says, stress that ‘there is no being out of place’ (17). Lems advocates a ‘turn towards lived experience of place’ (21). In moving through places, and not just through ‘indifferent space,’ Lems argues, people ‘shape them and are in turn shaped by them’ (22). Resonating Ingold’s wayfarers, showing how people move through – not across – the world in the quest for a better life.

Being-Here is an impressive book. It demonstrates the power of storytelling among people who were born in a country famed for its love of the art of storytelling. Mohamed Ibrahim, Omar and Halima, who fled their native country because of the war and violence and the disintegration of Somalia do not want to be labelled refugees. Through their life stories, a method creating ‘an understanding of humans as being born of and into the world, we get a more complex understanding of displacement’ (p. 51). We are looking at their everyday struggles, walking and talking with them, and getting used to ‘the lived messiness’ of the story-telling moment (38-43). Lems focus on ‘everyday acts of meaning-making’ in order to get a richer understanding of the ‘role of place in a world of movement’ (53). Her humane and intersubjective approach to the life worlds of Omar and Halima, linking her own experiences as an European academic immigrant in Australia to their cultural narratives, and her personal reflections on home and family to their stories about Somali family networks and ‘home building,’ creates an image of people who want to dwell in a place ‘open enough to perceive opportunities to move forward in one’s life’ (119). Melbourne is their home and they want their children to be recognized as Australians without having to excuse the migration history of the family. Omar says for instance:

‘Yes, I am Somali, and I am born Somali from one of the Somali families; however I didn’t chose to be born Somali; it just happened that way. But I believe Australia offered me more than what Somalia offered me in terms of the past and in the present’ (134).

Of course, memories from Somalia, the smell, the sky, the colors, the sounds, et cetera, is part of the ‘story.’ Some things of the past are easy to talk about, others are kept in silent painful stories. Drawing on Ricoeur’s concept of memory places, but connecting it to the present, Lems argues that memory places illustrate the ‘lived messiness of life’s temporal flows.’ In her creative autobiographical book ‘What the Oceans Remember’ (2019), Sonja Boon writes her family’s story and its movement between countries and continents through centuries. In the last section she writes: ‘Maybe origins are a mirage. Maybe belonging is a fiction, something each of us creates for ourselves. And maybe, then, home is the journey itself’ (262). For the Somali community in Melbourne, and most clearly through the voice of Halima, ‘home, place and family seem to almost become one’ (158). They have their shops and social events in Melbourne, keeping people connected to each other, and helping the unemployed and lonely to find new hopes for the future. They invite, according to Lems, an understanding of place allowing it to ‘touch and reach out to the wider world’ (157). Nevertheless, the loss of Somalia as a place to return ‘home’ to, its extreme destruction through the last decades (‘the age of desperate exodus,’as Ahmed Samatar calls it), is traumatizing. It is, says Halima, a lost place (178). Halima and others from her community do not give up, they work hard to establish a ‘place-bound stability’ and to avoid the ‘continuous state of limbo’ (204). They work hard ‘to belong’ (205). This contradicts images of nomads avoiding homeboundedness in the twenty-first century. It also opposes the simple ‘rootlessness’ as the expression of mobility and freedom. Paradoxically, many people experience roots ‘like an extra pair of wings,‘ says Hage (22).

Being-Here is a thought-provoking book unravelling the key role of storytelling in migrants’ movements, place-making and everyday struggle. Her study breaks out of the tautologies of the study of international migration, manifesting the openness, in its ambiguities and potentials, of human life.

§

Dr. Firouz Gaini is a professor of anthropology at the University of the Faroe Islands. Gaini has done research on young people, identity, place and gender. Young people’s migration plans and attachment to place (local identities) is one of the main topics of his ongoing research projects. Gaini is also one of the editors of a book on islands and gender to be published by Routledge in 2020.

 

Works cited:

Boon, S, 2019. What the Oceans Remember. Waterloo (Canada): Wilfrid Laurier University Press

Samatar, S. 2010. ‘Somalia: A Nation’s Literary Death Tops its Political Demise’ in M. Höhne and V. Luling (Eds.), Peace and Milk, Drought and War: Somali Culture, Society and Politics. New York: Columbia University Press, pp. 207-220

Ricoeur, P. 2004. Memory, History, Forgetting. Chicago IL: University of Chicago Press

© 2020 Firouz Gaini

Creative Commons License

Download as PDF